Sunday, August 22, 2010

DS or not?


As parents, we have tried to steer clear of too much of media exposure for the boys, and especially Winkie as the older one. I have already talked about how much TV had impacted our lives earlier on, and now, even though we have cable television, the boys watch only recorded programs on the DVR and that too not everyday. And all they are allowed to watch so far are Curious George, Little Einsteins and Mickey Mouse Clubhouse. We have watched these with them from time to time and the shows seem simple and childlike. We could expand their viewing library, but that would mean we would have to watch it ourselves first to see what would be right for them. And we have no time for that.


The boys, for their part, since they are not exposed to anything else, don't ask for anything else. For now, they are content watching just these shows.  It inevitably means, that Winkie is not savvy enough to hold his own in a conversation about anything else that a typical 7 year old boy watches. Which is no big loss according to me, but sometimes I wonder. Just a bit.


Like on the question of the peer pressure of buying a DS over this weekend. Having watched a few of his friends handle their own individual DS consoles and play interactive games, on a few occasions, the desire to have one of his own seized strongly. And we came to learn of it, when he hugged my legs tight, and shed a few self pitying tears. It certainly won our pity for him but not a confirmation that he could have one of his own. I spoke to a few friends, trying to get viewpoints to help us decide. The reason why there was even a decision to consider was obvious. Although our underlying belief (as naive as it gets) is that it IS possible to raise kids innocent of all these gadgets, doubt rears its ugly head from time to time, over whether it will make our child too innocent and hence socially inept to mingle and feel part of a crowd. We worry over him being the 'odd one out', and whether he will have the courage and the confidence to withstand that position.


Because at the end of the day, that's what it boils down to. If Winkie were capable of understanding why we impose these restrictions, and stand up to any pressure on the strength of these arguments, and feel that he is a normal kid, just like anyone else, no matter what they think, then there is no issue at all. But as adults itself, we grapple everyday with the weakness of insecurity and ego pressures, to think clearly on the strength of our own core belief system, so how then can we expect a child at such a tender age to become one with this great philosophy?


Yet, I cannot give up the belief that he will learn it one day and each stage of his life will give him opportunities to develop and exhibit it. And as parents, it is our solemn duty to open him up to this truth. That he is perfect in himself. That life is about the fulfillment of desire and also the sacrifice of it. That intelligence is about developing the ability to discriminate between the two kinds, and have the strength of resolve to say no to oneself. Its a tall order, but any worthy cause will never be short of a challenge. And the responsibility of one's life and character to mould, is perhaps the worthiest of it all.


Today, Winkie does not have a DS or a PS or whatever else acronym it is that captures the market fancy and frenzy. It doesn't mean that we will never buy him one, but for now, some part of his nature has not pushed him to push this with us. He has displayed a healthy curiosity as a child to experience what he sees his peers enjoying. And there is nothing wrong with that. It is only our more willful adult mind that casts our own doubts into the mix, making the matter more complex. Today, Winkie still revels in the idea of a quiet time. We had unlearned that precious lesson over the past several months, but now, I have got him back on that track again. Every afternoon, he has a choice to either take a nap if he is tired or spend some time quietly and preferably with a book. And to get him motivated, I have stocked him up on his favorite Magic Treehouse series. And every afternoon, when I enjoy my own quiet time, either with a book or a nap, I see him poring on chapter after chapter in this utter concentration, which I just love. So much that I have taken several pictures of him just reading. Read read read. And if he is done with the book, he knows how to stay within his own silence. He knows better than to wake me up from a nap, so he will just sit with some random object in his hands, sometimes as random as a pencil or my hairclip, and fly it up in the air, soft sounds coming from his throat, aiding in his mental game. Thus he patiently bides his time, until I am ready to come out of my own little cocoon and be interactive once more. And I think this is a very precious thing indeed. Being able to be with yourself, without boredom. And I'd like to keep this going for as long as possible!

14 comments:

ChoxBox said... Best Blogger Tips

Hi T. Realte to this big time.

My kids have access to the telly but most of the time it simply does not feature in our things-to-do list. There is enough and more to keep them busy otherwise - friends and books mostly. My kids are also not in Bollywood. I have not seen them suffer for it at least this far. No PSP or Wii here either.

About DS - we bought one for the older child for her 7th bday - her friends all had it and she seemed to like it too. She played with it for a few months, but almost always on a second thought. Right now its lying behind her books, untouched since the last sleepover when one of her friends wanted to check it out.

So my point is - a. as long as you are convinced you are doing the right thing, its okay to be different from other families (I know i’m preaching to the choir here but still) and b. often the novelty wears off very fast ;)

Jaya said... Best Blogger Tips

I do not comment here often Tharini,but I do read all our posts and I am too with you on this issue.
I too feel sometimes guilty when I say no these new hi-fi games to my 6 year old daughter but when I see her peers enjoying all these, I ask myself am I really something depriving her in her wonderful growing years ?
You know I just love to see my daughter also with the book in her hand reading all by herself..and that makes my day too :-)..
hugs and smiles

PG said... Best Blogger Tips

I too am an avid reader your blog posts, even if I don't manage to do it regularly or comment on them.
This hasn't been an issue for me until now, but soon, I assume.
All the same, I have given a little thought to it, as sooner than later it willbe y turn to decide too. The main criteria for me is, if I give it to him, in what ways it will impact sunny boy, to what extent and how much control I really will have over the situation. Will I be able to negotiate some rules that it doesn't get too much for him. These are my main fears. So, I'd like to postpone it as long as possible.
But, I think, there is nothing wrong in a DS or the likes as such, neither it is in not having them. He will get exposed to it through friends anyways!
At the end I will most importantly keep sunny boy in mind than my ideals.

--SS said... Best Blogger Tips

I read your blog and enjoy it for the most part, though this is the first time I've commented on here

I do think that Mickey Mouse clubhouse, Little Einsteins and Curious George may be a bit too childish for a 7 year old. I am impressed that he's watching those shows without complaining. Maybe something like Between the Lions, The General Electric company or even Word World may be more appropriate.

In an age where most 10-12 year olds have iPads, and kids as young as three play on the Wii, I think it's commendable that you are firm on your decision not to buy him a DS. How does he feel about it though ? Does he feel left out at school ? It's a fine line --- and only you can determine what's best for your family & kids.

Cantaloupes.Amma (CA) said... Best Blogger Tips

We bought a Wii few months back and after the initial excitement period, she hardly uses it. It is more likely to be used by BP or me.
TV time, well the kids are allowed to watch TV in our house, but there is no set routine right now. During summer break, I guess there was a definite pattern where they watched pre-recorded program for about 30 mins a day. (Sid the science kid shows and Super Why shows) There were days when they begged for more TV time .. of course we gave in some times, but mostly stuck to 30 mins. For the past few days though, we haven't really watched much TV and the kids don't seem to care much.

Tharini said... Best Blogger Tips

Chox : I take heart in what you've said. That gives me hope and impetus that it is possible.

Jaya : I guess we're struggling with the same set of feelings.

PG : You seem to have a good balance of thought worked out. Good for you! :)

SS : Thanks so much for the suggestions. Its good to know which shows are nice to check out, so we can help him diversify a bit. Though we don't feel that Curious George is too childish at all. Its really informative and there is so much of logical reasoning, and Winkie really seems to like it, so for however long he wants to watch it. :) To answer your question, he felt the pang of it that particular weekend, but he's not asked us for it since then at home. So I am thinking its not a big huge deal with him right now.

CA : That's exactly what I want to avoid, for as long as possible. Making an investment that will have such a minimal shelf life. Wii is tempting, because it is still novel for us, but we already have a game table at home, which will be sorely neglected if we buy him something else. What he still wants now is more of our time with him to play with.

starry eyed said... Best Blogger Tips

Tharini, this touched a chord. we haven't had a TV for over 7 years. We keep re-examining this...but frankly there is no time for TV and so many things we could do more with the kids. We compensate in many different ways...will link back to you sometime when I do a post on this decision of ours. We live a very techno-phobic life. It feels wonderful and healthier. But your words reflect my concerns very well.

dipali said... Best Blogger Tips

I love the amount of thought you are giving the matter. He's so beautifully absorbed in his book in the picture. No idea, actually, what you should do- it seems like something of which the novelty will wear off real soon, but he may keep craving it till he has it:(

Sneha said... Best Blogger Tips

Tharini,
we don't have TV from the past 4 years. my kids never complained about TV till now. They are always busy doing something or the other. They have learnt so many things on their own. My son learnt to climb trees these days he says he loves it. He him self learnt to read telugu, tamil, hindi and english. All these things happened because they have lots of time.

Tharini said... Best Blogger Tips

Starry : Thanks for taking the time to read and write to me. It helps me consolidate my position. And I love the term 'techno-phobic'. I think it could very well become a catch phrase. :)

Dipali : Yes, novelty would wear off soon. And thankfully enough, he hasn't brought it up even once since that day. :)

Sneha : That's truly amazing. 4 languages!! Wow. You're right. No-TV frees up a lot of time for everything else! I'm inspired all over again. Thanks so much for sharing.

ChoxBox said... Best Blogger Tips

@Sneha: Nodded my head vigorously at your last line.

Anonymous said... Best Blogger Tips

DS :-) He is ready.... my thought is you can introduce it to him but have restriction on the usage. But you know thats me... :-) my way of thinking is try everything and then decide on your choices.
Regards,
Antro

Anonymous said... Best Blogger Tips

Waiting for ur blog on Krishna Jayanthi!!

starry eyed said... Best Blogger Tips

Hi Tharini...remembered this post of yours...I'd done a post recently and there was an interesting discussion on TV and gaming...thought I'd leave a link like I'd said

http://starsinmeyes.wordpress.com/2010/12/08/playing-games/

Post a Comment

Write to me!